Summer camps are competing with a $40 billion industry


Camps are competing with a $40 billion industry.

Not other camps. Not enrichment programs. Not Disney World.

Youth travel and competitive sports.

This number keeps growing. The infrastructure keeps expanding. And parents keep choosing sports over summer camp, often spending three to five times as much.

The irony? Parents are choosing sports for exactly the things camps do better.

What Parents Say They Want

We survey families year in and year out about what they look for in their kids’ activities. In our most recent survey, 72% of affluent families have their children in travel or competitive sports.

The top answers of why parents are choosing sports are that they feel these needs are being met:

  1. Skill development
  2. Social interaction
  3. Health and fitness

But camps train staff specifically on social interaction. Camps build skill progression into curriculum. Camps provide healthier group environments and more holistic development than most sports programs.

When it comes to what parents actually want, camps are the shining star.

Why Sports Win Anyway

Sports have structural advantages that camps don’t.

They operate year-round and locally. Kids see the same friends constantly. Parents form tight social communities. I know this one personally. When one of my daughters stopped playing softball, we felt it. I heard from other parents all the time some version of, “Come back! We miss you!”

Plus, there’s a fear of falling behind if kids take a summer off.

The pressure is intense because everyone believes their child is on a path to something great.

And the community is powerful. Parents stay with sports because all the other parents are doing it. Their identity becomes tied to team membership.

Even when sports are financially and emotionally draining, the social pressure keeps them in foldout chairs on the sidelines.

How Camps Can Compete

This isn’t about replacing sports. Most families won’t leave travel teams for camp.

It’s about positioning camp as “yes, and.”

Yes, keep playing sports. But know that camps provide all kinds of things organized sports often don't:

Skill development through progression → Not just repetition, but intentional curriculum that builds over time.

Social interaction without performance pressure → Connection and identity formation in environments designed for growth, not competition.

Healthier routines → Outdoors, movement, sunlight, hydration, and three meals a day (which is a key distinction)

There are plenty more, obviously, and it’s important for camps to know their own list.

The Communication Opportunity

Camps can’t out-spend a $40 billion industry. They can’t operate year-round in every local community.

But camps can communicate their unique value clearly.

When camp messaging emphasizes skill progression, social growth, and developmental outcomes (the exact things parents say they want btw) they become complementary to sports, not competitive with them.

This means talking about:

How camp staff are trained in facilitating social interaction.

How skill-building happens through intentional curriculum design.

How communication keeps families connected to their child’s experience.

These aren’t abstract benefits. They’re the specific things parents told us they wish sports programs did better.

The Positioning Shift

The camps winning this competition aren’t trying to replace sports programs.

They’re helping parents see what camp uniquely provides by making the case that kids need both.

Get the structure and community of sports, sure, but also add on the holistic development and social growth of camp.

When camps position themselves as “yes, and” instead of “either/or,” families start to stop seeing it as a choice. It’s more about complementary experiences that serve different developmental needs.

The Bottom Line

Look, travel sports aren’t going away. Quite the opposite, really. The industry is only getting bigger and more organized.

But camps have something sports programs struggle to replicate:

Intentional development of the whole child, delivered by trained staff, in environments designed specifically for growth.

The question isn’t whether camps can compete with a $40 billion industry.

It’s whether camps can communicate their value clearly enough that parents choose both.

Sincerely,
Dan Weir

Senior Consultant at Immersive1st

dan@immersive1st.com

Featured Open Position

Senior Director of Camps - JCC Abrams Camps

Location: East Windsor, NJ

Compensation: $75k-$90k + Generous PTO + Flexible Hybrid Schedule + Additional Benefits

Description: Lead a premier Jewish day camp by guiding staff, programs, and community engagement to create joyful and transformative experiences for campers.

Summer Staffing Analysis Survey

Why participate?

✅ It takes just 8-10 minutes

✅ It’s 100% confidential (all personal details removed)

✅ There is a free summary of results delivered to all participants

📈

How does Immersive1st recruit talent →

🎨

Meet the people behind Immersive1st

Learn more about Immersive1st's Approach

video preview

Share this email with a colleague!

Looking for jobs in summer camps and nonprofits? Subscribe for new openings and job search tips.

Hiring? The next issue will show how your organization can reach the right candidates.

Immersive1st

Subscribe to the Immersive1st newsletter for new openings and smart job search tips. Hiring? The next issue will show how your organization can reach the right candidates.

Read more from Immersive1st

What year-round sport are you playing? What academic track are you on? These kinds of specialization questions seem to come earlier and earlier for kids. And parents are 100% feeling the pressure to make it happen. Focus and expertise are great, but this narrowing is creating anxiety in all groups, with kids less and less willing to try new things or take risks. And that means self-exploration gets squeezed out. We already know (and have covered) leadership, purpose, and belonging as some...

Step into any summer camp in the country during the months of July and August and you’ll see something crazy. Groups of kids (gasp) walking, talking, running, laughing together. It shouldn’t feel like some outlier outcome. But it’s increasingly so. Kids are more connected digitally than ever. More group chats. More likes and reactions. More ways to reach each other instantly. And also, lonelier than they’ve ever been. Meeting someone has always taken a certain amount of courage. But screen...

Parents want confident kids. So they sign those same kids up for activities, praise effort, and celebrate small wins. But confidence isn’t built through praise. Confidence comes from knowing you matter. From feeling needed. From contributing something real. Kids are struggling with confidence because they’re missing purpose. This is part 2 in our series on what camp does better than the alternatives consuming family calendars and budgets. Part 1 covered leadership development [Link]....