The #1 way to get more kids to summer camp


Back in my days overseeing multiple camps, one of them had a 25% higher retention rate than all the others.

The Farm Camp Program. Jennie was in charge and she got nearly every kid to come back to camp.

She wasn’t a trained salesperson. In fact, she was a trained librarian which is about as opposite of sales as you can get.

So what did she do to drive retention north of 85% with 200 kids over the summer?

She called 10 families every morning. That’s it.

That’s the retention playbook.

Most calls went to voicemail. Maybe one real conversation out of 10. But the voicemails alone showed care.

I’ve seen this pattern everywhere. Gary at Camp Nock-A-Mixon does something similar. 90% retention. When I asked him what’s different, he said, “We keep them in the loop like they are family.”

Nothing fancy. Just consistent contact.

The Data

Travis Allison, Eric Wittenberg, and I recently surveyed 90 camps, both overnight and day.

The finding: when camps got families on the phone, they closed the deal by answering their questions.

Think about your camper recruitment efforts (aka enrollment funnel). Becoming aware of the camp is at the top, then considering options, then nudging to help finalize the registration. Emails handle becoming aware of the camp. Phone calls handle everything else. And many camps struggle with the “everything else”.

In plain math language:

50% retention is the floor. Some camps are below this, but it’s the first goal.

60-65% is good.

North of 80% is great.

Every camp, of any size, can get to north of 80%. If you’re not there, chances are you’re not making enough phone calls. You’re not building strong enough relationships with families. That’s really it.

Why Camps Don’t Do It And Why Phone Calls Work

The same objections appear all the time.

“It’s not worth it.”

“I feel inauthentic doing sales calls.”

“Parents will find the information online.”

“I’m afraid of the answer I’m going to get.”

These are all real feelings. They’re just not good reasons to avoid the phone.

Email goes to a pile of several hundred messages a day. A phone call rings through and a voicemail is likely to get noticed.

Parents want dialogue. You can’t assume they’ll find everything online and digest it on their own. They want to interact with the information, ask questions, hear a real person. Especially when it’s about their child.

The world is filling up with AI and automations. Phone calls are still unmistakably human, and a signal of care that nothing else replicates.

The Prescription

Put all your families on a spreadsheet. Call 10 every morning.

Start with the camp families you talk to the most to get comfortable. Then go to unenrolled leads. Then enrolled families. Then alumni. Ask if they know anyone who might be interested.

You don’t need a script or training. Remember, Jennie was a librarian. You just need to pick up the phone.

Phone calls aren’t complicated, and many camps won’t do it. Which is exactly why the ones who do pull ahead.

Retention a problem? Pick up the phone.

Sincerely,
Dan Weir

Senior Consultant at Immersive1st

​dan@immersive1st.com​


Featured Open Position

Director of Camp Turner (Seasonal) - OLV Charities

Location: Salamanca, NY

Compensation: $900-$1,000 per week + housing provided

Description: Lead a 100+ year-old Catholic camp by guiding daily camp life focused on faith and adventure in Allegany NY State Park, with a dedicated team.

See us at the ACA NY & NJ's Tri-State Camp Conference!

Sessions with David Phillips

  • Ready or Not? The Power of Succession Planning
  • Creating Meaningful (and Sustainable) Partnerships with Parents of Campers AND Staff!
  • From Governance to Growth: Activating Leadership Volunteers and Owners for Success

Sessions with Dan Weir

  • Foundations of a Strong Camp Marketing Plan
  • Developing Future Camp Leaders with CIT Programs
  • The Parent Perspective: Understanding Families’ Summer Choices in 2026

Hunter Gold is offering free consultations to help camps review their finances.

📈

How does Immersive1st recruit talent →​

🎨

​Meet the people behind Immersive1st →​

Learn more about Immersive1st's Approach

video preview​

Share this email with a colleague!

Looking for jobs in summer camps and nonprofits? Subscribe for new openings and job search tips.

Hiring? The next issue will show how your organization can reach the right candidates.

Immersive1st

Subscribe to the Immersive1st newsletter for new openings and smart job search tips. Hiring? The next issue will show how your organization can reach the right candidates.

Read more from Immersive1st

In the span of the last year, and really in the last several months, AI has become one of, if not the biggest topic of conversation in the camp world. And that’s specifically from the people running camps. Which has meant spending that time trying to figure out, while watching, how camp directors are figuring it out. With this, I see three buckets they’re falling into. Let’s talk them out and see which one might be a bit of a trap. Bucket 1. Using it to solve problems These are camps using AI...

September can be a split-screen month for summer camps. Most are full steam ahead into fall, getting ready for next summer. And that’s always a great feeling. But a few just wrapped July and August, walking straight into the biggest change an organization can face: an empty seat at the very top. It's what happens when a director leaves, and now the camp is making a change. Sometimes this looks like an interim director coming into the fold. And other times, a different kind of transition is...

I got a call this week from a camp that runs day camp in two cities. They want to add more. You’re probably saying, “Oh, that’s a nice problem to have.” But really, the questions and issues they’re facing apply, in many ways, to most camps and operations. They know they can’t just take the current setup and multiply it by three by force of personality alone. Their program works because they are managing it. Every day, in every corner. They can feel when something is off. What they need to...