|
Tell me if your camp (or some camp you know) has experienced something like this before. Things are going well or even great, numbers are a bit up, and everyone thinks to themselves, sort of collectively, “It’s time to build something.” So then planning ramps up. What could we build to expand the program and where can we put the building? How can we make the site better, drive revenue and improve camp? Makes sense. Camps, like all businesses, want to improve and even grow. And sometimes one of the best ways to do that is to improve what you have or get bigger in some way. So you get plans for the new dining hall, or the new rec center, or the new program offering (I’m looking at you, pickleball), or the winterization of more buildings so the place can be used in those colder months. All great ideas. All potentially massive issues if not handled correctly. My Immersive1st partner David Phillips has written about this before. The AlbatrossAn albatross is the thing a camp builds that doesn’t end up working. It could be a building, or winterization, or a new program. The specifics don’t matter as much as the pattern, which goes like this: The idea sounds great → Probably is a great idea on paper → Camp gets excited → Fundraising numbers get thrown around → Loans get considered → Plan gets drawn up and then… The building goes up or is improved or the new program launches. And… something doesn’t quite work. Could be a number of things. Maybe the building doesn’t fit what families want or your long-term program vision demands. Or you didn’t consider the added operational costs (heating, additional staff, Wi-Fi , hotel-level food, preventive maintenance) that the retreat revenue can’t cover. Or the new program never catches on. Now the camp has a reconfigured or new building, or a program, or new (and very warm) cabins that eat cash without generating return. All while loan or donor payments are, hopefully, getting made. That is the albatross. And it happens more than you would think. And the “please help, this isn’t working” calls David and I end up on often come from camps that did the planning themselves. The Three TracksDavid has spent over two decades walking camps through comprehensive program, site and fundraising planning (the thing that stops the albatross before it happens). His version of the fix is what he calls a three-track approach. Three conversations that have to be happening at the same time, not one after the other. Operations → The existing camp has to keep improving while the new thing is planned in order to absorb it easily. Going from “we have a plan” to “the building is open” is usually 1 to 3 years. Planning → Not just the physical master plan itself. But elements like Board readiness, human resources, and outreach to families all fit in here. A Board or ownership group that can’t comprehensively prepare for a capital project and a team that can’t absorb the new facility will undo even the best plan. Philanthropy → The fundraising conversation has to start and run in unison when the planning does, not after (camps miss this all the time). Donors who feel like they’re part of the process from the beginning invest more. And many have real site-development experience; they’ll add to the plan if you bring them in early. The reason to run all three at once is that when any one track falls behind, the plan starts to go off the rails (literally!). The building, if it even gets built, goes up without the program ready to absorb it or the donors ready to pay for it. That is how the albatross happens. Not from any single wrong decision. From the three tracks never meeting up. Sincerely, Senior Consultant at Immersive1st Learn more about Immersive1st's Approach |
Subscribe to the Immersive1st newsletter for new openings and smart job search tips. Hiring? The next issue will show how your organization can reach the right candidates.
Are you selling care, or are you selling investment? That’s the question I ask almost anytime I’m walking a camp property with a camp exec, director or owner. So many times, folks don’t quite know how to answer when it’s put this way. But the question raises something we see over and over in this amazing field. A lot of camps are already doing the work of investment. They’re just marketing it like care. Let me define the difference. Care means “watch my kid.” A parent looking for care is...
Executive search partnership brings nationally recognized camp leader with more than 30 years of nonprofit, diabetes camping, and industry leadership experience to Florida Diabetes Camp. November 11, 2026 Immersive1st is pleased to announce the successful completion of an executive search in partnership with Florida Diabetes Camp (FDC), resulting in the appointment of Kat Shreve as the organization's new Executive Director. Kat Shreve brings more than 30 years of nonprofit leadership, youth...
I looked across the Zoom window at Hunter and he’s there just shaking his head. It’s one of those slow, sad, side-to-side (while sighing) shakes. The ones you see when someone is looking at the same problem he’s seen over and over. The kind that bums you out a little bit. Hunter is the finance expert on our Immersive1st team. He’s an accountant, a former day camp owner, former nonprofit executive, and a fractional CFO for camps around the country. Need a real look at numbers? Call Hunter. He...